| 2025 | 42 | Maxime Raynaud | 2 | Stanford |
| 2024 | 13 | Devin Carter | 1 | Providence |
| 2024 | 45 | Jamal Shead (↳TOR) | 2 | Houston |
| 2023 | 24 | Olivier-Maxence Prosper (↳DAL) | 1 | Marquette |
| 2023 | 38 | Jordan Walsh (↳BOS) | 2 | Arkansas |
| 2023 | 54 | Jalen Slawson | 2 | Furman University |
| 2022 | 4 | Keegan Murray | 1 | Iowa |
| 2022 | 37 | Jaden Hardy (↳DAL) | 2 | |
| 2021 | 9 | Davion Mitchell | 1 | Baylor |
| 2021 | 39 | Neemias Queta | 2 | Utah State University |
| 2020 | 12 | Tyrese Haliburton | 1 | Iowa State |
| 2020 | 35 | Xavier Tillman (↳MEM) | 2 | Michigan State |
| 2020 | 43 | Jahmi'us Ramsey | 2 | Texas Tech |
| 2020 | 52 | Kenyon Martin (↳HOU) | 2 | |
| 2019 | 40 | Justin James | 2 | Wyoming |
| 2019 | 47 | Ignas Brazdeikis (↳NYK) | 2 | Michigan |
| 2019 | 60 | Vanja Marinković | 2 | |
| 2018 | 2 | Marvin Bagley | 1 | Duke |
| 2018 | 37 | Gary Trent (↳POR) | 2 | Duke |
| 2017 | 5 | De'Aaron Fox | 1 | Kentucky |
| 2017 | 10 | Zach Collins (↳POR) | 1 | Gonzaga |
| 2017 | 34 | Frank Mason | 2 | Kansas |
| 2016 | 8 | Marquese Chriss (↳PHO) | 1 | Washington |
| 2016 | 59 | Isaiah Cousins | 2 | Oklahoma |
| 2015 | 6 | Willie Cauley-Stein | 1 | Kentucky |
| 2014 | 8 | Nik Stauskas | 1 | Michigan |
| 2013 | 7 | Ben McLemore | 1 | Kansas |
| 2013 | 36 | Ray McCallum | 2 | Detroit Mercy |
| 2012 | 5 | Thomas Robinson | 1 | Kansas |
| 2012 | 36 | Orlando Johnson (↳IND) | 2 | UC Santa Barbara |
| 2011 | 7 | Bismack Biyombo (↳CHA) | 1 | |
| 2011 | 35 | Tyler Honeycutt | 2 | UCLA |
| 2011 | 60 | Isaiah Thomas | 2 | Washington |
| 2010 | 5 | DeMarcus Cousins | 1 | Kentucky |
| 2010 | 33 | Hassan Whiteside | 2 | Marshall |
| 2009 | 4 | Tyreke Evans | 1 | Memphis |
| 2009 | 23 | Omri Casspi | 1 | |
| 2009 | 31 | Jeff Ayres (↳POR) | 2 | Arizona State |
| 2008 | 12 | Jason Thompson | 1 | Rider University |
| 2008 | 42 | Sean Singletary (↳HOU ↳PHO) | 2 | Virginia |
| 2008 | 43 | Patrick Ewing (↳HOU ↳NYK) | 2 | Georgetown |
| 2007 | 10 | Spencer Hawes | 1 | Washington |
| 2006 | 19 | Quincy Douby | 1 | Rutgers University |
| 2005 | 23 | Francisco García | 1 | Louisville |
| 2004 | 26 | Kevin Martin | 1 | Western Carolina University |
| 2004 | 48 | Ricky Minard | 2 | Morehead State University |
| 2002 | 28 | Dan Dickau (↳ATL) | 1 | Gonzaga |
| 2002 | 58 | Corsley Edwards | 2 | Central Connecticut State University |
| 2001 | 25 | Gerald Wallace | 1 | Alabama |
| 2001 | 55 | Maurice Jeffers | 2 | Saint Louis |
| 2000 | 16 | Hedo Türkoğlu | 1 | |
| 2000 | 45 | Jabari Smith | 2 | LSU |
| 1999 | 45 | Ryan Robertson | 2 | Kansas |
| 1998 | 7 | Jason Williams | 1 | Florida |
| 1998 | 36 | Jerome James | 2 | Florida A&M |
| 1997 | 11 | Tariq Abdul-Wahad | 1 | San Jose State |
| 1997 | 40 | Anthony Johnson | 2 | College of Charleston |
| 1996 | 14 | Peja Stojaković | 1 | |
| 1996 | 41 | Jason Sasser | 2 | Texas Tech |
| 1995 | 13 | Corliss Williamson | 1 | Arkansas |
| 1995 | 47 | Tyus Edney | 2 | UCLA |
| 1995 | 51 | Dejan Bodiroga | 2 | |
| 1994 | 8 | Brian Grant | 1 | Xavier |
| 1994 | 35 | Michael Smith | 2 | Providence |
| 1994 | 51 | Lawrence Funderburke | 2 | Ohio State |
| 1993 | 7 | Bobby Hurley | 1 | Duke |
| 1993 | 31 | Evers Burns | 2 | Maryland |
| 1993 | 44 | Alex Holcombe | 2 | Baylor |
| 1993 | 52 | Mike Peplowski | 2 | Michigan State |
| 1992 | 7 | Walt Williams | 1 | Maryland |
| 1992 | 54 | Brett Roberts | 2 | Morehead State University |
| 1991 | 3 | Billy Owens (↳GSW) | 1 | Syracuse |
| 1991 | 27 | Pete Chilcutt | 1 | UNC |
| 1991 | 31 | Randy Brown | 2 | New Mexico State |
| 1991 | 42 | Steve Hood | 2 | James Madison University |
| 1990 | 7 | Lionel Simmons | 1 | La Salle |
| 1990 | 14 | Travis Mays | 1 | Texas |
| 1990 | 18 | Duane Causwell | 1 | Temple |
| 1990 | 23 | Anthony Bonner | 1 | Saint Louis |
| 1990 | 40 | Bimbo Coles (↳MIA) | 2 | Virginia Tech |
| 1989 | 1 | Pervis Ellison | 1 | Louisville |
| 1988 | 18 | Ricky Berry | 1 | San Jose State |
| 1988 | 29 | Vinny Del Negro | 2 | NC State |
| 1987 | 6 | Kenny Smith | 1 | UNC |
| 1987 | 51 | Sven Meyer | 3 | Oregon |
| 1987 | 74 | Joe Arlauckas | 4 | Niagara University |
| 1987 | 97 | Vernon Carr | 5 | Michigan State |
| 1987 | 120 | Daryl Thomas | 6 | Indiana |
| 1987 | 143 | Scott Adubato | 7 | Upsala College |
| 1986 | 17 | Harold Pressley | 1 | Villanova |
| 1986 | 34 | Johnny Rogers | 2 | University of California, Irvine |
| 1986 | 57 | Bruce Douglas | 3 | Illinois |
| 1986 | 80 | Alvin Franklin | 4 | Houston |
| 1986 | 91 | Bob Beecher | 4 | Virginia Tech |
| 1986 | 103 | Keith Morrison | 5 | Washington State |
| 1986 | 126 | John Flowers | 6 | UNLV |
| 1986 | 149 | Ron Rankin | 7 | SE Missouri State |
| 1985 | 6 | Joe Kleine | 1 | Arkansas |
| 1985 | 51 | Charles Bradley | 3 | South Florida |
| 1985 | 66 | Michael Adams | 3 | Boston College |
| 1985 | 76 | Willie Simmons | 4 | Louisiana Tech |
| 1985 | 98 | Bob Lojewski | 5 | Saint Joseph's |
| 1985 | 120 | Charles Balentine | 6 | Arkansas |
| 1985 | 145 | Alton Lee Gipson | 7 | Florida State |
| 1984 | 9 | Otis Thorpe | 1 | Providence |
| 1984 | 54 | Roosevelt Chapman | 3 | Dayton |
| 1984 | 56 | Jeff Allen | 3 | St. John's |
| 1984 | 80 | Carl Henry | 4 | Kansas |
| 1984 | 102 | Jim Foster | 5 | South Carolina |
| 1984 | 126 | Bruce Vanley | 6 | Tulsa |
| 1984 | 148 | Chipper Harris | 7 | Robert Morris University (PA) |
| 1984 | 172 | Nate Rollins | 8 | Fort Hays State University |
| 1984 | 193 | Greg Turner | 9 | Auburn |
| 1984 | 216 | Victor Coleman | 10 | Northwest Missouri State University |
| 1983 | 13 | Ennis Whatley (↳CHI) | 1 | Alabama |
| 1983 | 38 | Chris McNealy (↳CHI) | 2 | San Jose State |
| 1983 | 60 | Steve Harriel | 3 | Washington State |
| 1983 | 84 | Mike Jackson | 4 | Wyoming |
| 1983 | 106 | Lorenza Andrews | 5 | Oklahoma State |
| 1983 | 130 | Alvis Rogers | 6 | Wake Forest |
| 1983 | 152 | Dane Suttle | 7 | Pepperdine |
| 1983 | 176 | Preston Neumayr | 8 | UC-Davis |
| 1983 | 197 | Bernard Hill | 9 | Oklahoma Panhandle State University |
| 1983 | 219 | Aaron Haskins | 10 | Washington State |
| 1982 | 5 | LaSalle Thompson | 1 | Texas |
| 1982 | 17 | Brook Steppe | 1 | Georgia Tech |
| 1982 | 51 | Jim Johnstone (↳ATL ↳SAS) | 3 | Wake Forest |
| 1982 | 74 | Mike Sanders | 4 | UCLA |
| 1982 | 97 | Kenny Simpson | 5 | Grambling State University |
| 1982 | 120 | Poncho Wright | 6 | Louisville |
| 1982 | 143 | Perry Range | 7 | Illinois |
| 1982 | 166 | Ed Nealy | 8 | Kansas State |
| 1982 | 189 | Jack Moore | 9 | Nebraska |
| 1982 | 210 | Robert Estes | 10 | Iowa State |
| 1981 | 7 | Steve Johnson | 1 | Oregon State |
| 1981 | 17 | Kevin Loder | 1 | Alabama State University |
| 1981 | 29 | Eddie Johnson | 2 | Illinois |
| 1981 | 58 | Curtis Berry | 3 | Missouri |
| 1981 | 78 | Kenny Dennard | 4 | Duke |
| 1981 | 82 | B.B. Davis | 4 | Lamar |
| 1981 | 104 | U.S. Reed | 5 | Arkansas |
| 1981 | 128 | Brian Walker | 6 | Purdue |
| 1981 | 150 | Clinton Wheeler | 7 | William Paterson University |
| 1981 | 173 | Randy Smithson | 8 | Wichita State |
| 1981 | 194 | Mike Perry | 9 | Richmond |
| 1981 | 214 | Mark Wilson | 10 | Fort Hays State University |
| 1980 | 16 | Hawkeye Whitney | 1 | NC State |
| 1980 | 62 | Tony Murphy | 3 | Southern University and A&M College |
| 1980 | 108 | Kelvin Blakely | 5 | Eastern Michigan |
| 1980 | 131 | Trent Grooms | 6 | Kent State University |
| 1980 | 154 | Arnold McDowell | 7 | Montana State |
| 1980 | 193 | Charley Cole | 9 | Delta State University |
| 1979 | 18 | Reggie King | 1 | Alabama |
| 1979 | 62 | Terry Crosby | 3 | Tennessee |
| 1979 | 85 | John McCullough | 4 | Oklahoma |
| 1979 | 105 | Curtis Watkins | 5 | DePaul |
| 1979 | 126 | Bob Roma | 6 | Princeton |
| 1979 | 145 | Nick Daniels | 7 | Xavier |
| 1979 | 164 | Tony Vann | 8 | |
| 1979 | 181 | Gary Wilson | 9 | Southern Illinois |
| 1979 | 200 | Russell Saunders | 10 | New Mexico |
| 1978 | 2 | Phil Ford | 1 | UNC |
| 1978 | 49 | Jeff Cook | 3 | Idaho State University |
| 1978 | 52 | Mike Russell | 3 | Texas Tech |
| 1978 | 70 | Jeffrey Crompton (↳DEN) | 4 | UNC |
| 1978 | 93 | Derrick Clairborne | 5 | UMass |
| 1978 | 114 | Jim Krivacs | 6 | Texas |
| 1978 | 136 | Charles McMillian | 7 | University of North Texas |
| 1978 | 155 | Ron Hammye | 8 | Bowling Green |
| 1977 | 2 | Otis Birdsong | 1 | Houston |
| 1977 | 31 | Eddie Owens | 2 | UNLV |
| 1977 | 45 | Bill Paterno | 3 | Notre Dame |
| 1977 | 53 | John Kuester | 3 | UNC |
| 1977 | 75 | Larry Williams | 4 | Texas Southern |
| 1977 | 97 | Bob Chapman | 5 | Michigan State |
| 1977 | 119 | Bob Cooper | 6 | Providence |
| 1977 | 139 | Caitlyn Jenner | 7 | Graceland University |
| 1976 | 3 | Richard Washington | 1 | UCLA |
| 1976 | 54 | Clarence Ramsey | 4 | Washington |
| 1976 | 71 | Willie Hodge | 5 | Duke |
| 1976 | 89 | Andre McCarter | 6 | UCLA |
| 1976 | 107 | Craig Prosser | 7 | Canisius |
| 1976 | 125 | Mike Davis | 8 | Bradley |
| 1976 | 143 | Dave Logan | 9 | Colorado |
| 1976 | 160 | Terry Bailey | 10 | University of North Texas |
| 1975 | 10 | Bill Robinzine | 1 | DePaul |
| 1975 | 13 | Bob Bigelow | 1 | Penn |
| 1975 | 31 | Glenn Hansen | 2 | LSU |
| 1975 | 49 | Bob Guyette | 3 | Kentucky |
| 1975 | 67 | Kevin Cluess | 4 | St. John's |
| 1975 | 85 | Ed Stahl | 5 | UNC |
| 1975 | 103 | Clint Chapman | 6 | USC |
| 1975 | 121 | Wayne Croft | 7 | Clemson |
| 1975 | 139 | Jim Bostic | 8 | New Mexico State |
| 1974 | 6 | Scott Wedman | 1 | Colorado |
| 1974 | 24 | Len Kosmalski | 2 | Tennessee |
| 1974 | 60 | Lloyd Batts | 4 | Cincinnati |
| 1974 | 78 | Terry Compton | 5 | Vanderbilt |
| 1974 | 96 | Ron Kennedy | 6 | Arizona |
| 1974 | 114 | Mark Brown | 7 | Missouri Western State College |
| 1974 | 132 | Richie O'Connor | 8 | Fairfield |
| 1974 | 150 | Jeff Dawson | 9 | Illinois |
| 1974 | 167 | Dennis White | 10 | Arkansas |
| 1973 | 7 | Ron Behagen | 1 | Minnesota |
| 1973 | 20 | Mike D'Antoni | 2 | Marshall |
| 1973 | 25 | Larry McNeill | 2 | Marquette |
| 1973 | 76 | M.L. Carr | 5 | Guilford College |
| 1973 | 93 | Mike Quick | 6 | San Francisco |
| 1973 | 110 | Mike Jeffries | 7 | Missouri |
| 1973 | 127 | Mike Williams | 8 | Kentucky Wesleyan College |
| 1973 | 143 | James Brown | 9 | Dartmouth College |
| 1973 | 157 | Ernie Kusnyer | 10 | Kansas State |
| 1972 | 19 | Sam Sibert | 2 | Kentucky State University |
| 1972 | 28 | Mike Ratliff | 2 | University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
| 1972 | 38 | Ron Riley | 3 | USC |
| 1972 | 53 | Frank Schade | 4 | University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
| 1972 | 68 | David Bustion | 5 | Denver |
| 1972 | 86 | Jerry Crocker | 6 | Guilford College |
| 1972 | 102 | Mike Sneed | 7 | Fayetteville State University |
| 1972 | 119 | Jerry Clack | 8 | Oklahoma State |
| 1972 | 134 | Steve McMahon | 9 | Merrimack College |
| 1972 | 148 | David Hall | 10 | Kansas State |
| 1972 | 159 | Floyd Mathew | 11 | Northern Arizona University |
| 1972 | 168 | Len Baltimore | 12 | George Washington |
| 1972 | 177 | Kent Scott | 13 | Pitt |
| 1972 | 183 | Bob Allen | 14 | Missouri |
| 1972 | 190 | Mike Jeffries | 15 | Oklahoma State |
| 1972 | 195 | Mike Peterson | 16 | Nebraska |
| 1971 | 4 | Ken Durrett | 1 | La Salle |
| 1971 | 21 | John Mengelt | 2 | Auburn |
| 1971 | 31 | Joe Bergman | 2 | Creighton |
| 1971 | 38 | Rich Yunkus | 3 | Georgia Tech |
| 1971 | 55 | Sid Catlett | 4 | Notre Dame |
| 1971 | 72 | Jimmie Guymon | 5 | Eastern New Mexico University |
| 1971 | 73 | Tyrone Marioneaux | 5 | Loyola New Orleans |
| 1971 | 89 | Gil McGregor | 6 | Wake Forest |
| 1971 | 106 | Ollie Shannon | 7 | Minnesota |
| 1971 | 123 | Frank Fitzgerald | 8 | Boston College |
| 1970 | 5 | Sam Lacey | 1 | New Mexico State |
| 1970 | 19 | Tiny Archibald | 2 | Texas-El Paso |
| 1970 | 22 | Doug Cook | 2 | Davidson |
| 1970 | 39 | Greg Hyder | 3 | Eastern New Mexico University |
| 1970 | 56 | Wade Fuller | 4 | Loyola Chicago |
| 1970 | 73 | Uluss Thompson | 5 | Wiley College |
| 1970 | 90 | Charles Bishop | 6 | Louisiana Tech |
| 1970 | 107 | Mike Bernard | 7 | Kentucky State University |
| 1970 | 124 | Joel McBride | 8 | Augusta State University |
| 1970 | 141 | Bob Mabry | 9 | University of Rio Grande |
| 1970 | 158 | Carl Johnson | 10 | Gustavus Adolphus |
| 1970 | 173 | Ted Hillary | 11 | Saint Joseph's College |
| 1970 | 186 | Reggie Roach | 12 | Virginia State University |
| 1970 | 196 | Larry Gray | 13 | Huston-Tillotson University |
| 1970 | 206 | Andy Jennings | 14 | Alderson-Broaddus College |
| 1970 | 216 | Mike Neer | 15 | Washington & Lee University |
| 1970 | 225 | Paul Favorite | 16 | Georgetown |
| 1969 | 8 | Herm Gilliam | 1 | Purdue |
| 1969 | 37 | Luther Rackley | 3 | Xavier |
| 1969 | 41 | Luther Green | 3 | Long Island University |
| 1969 | 51 | Ron Sanford | 4 | New Mexico |
| 1969 | 65 | Jake Ford | 5 | University of Maryland Eastern Shore |
| 1969 | 79 | Mel Coleman | 6 | University of Wisconsin-Stout |
| 1969 | 93 | L.C. Bowen | 7 | Bradley |
| 1969 | 107 | Merton Bancroft | 8 | Missouri State |
| 1969 | 121 | James Hurley | 9 | Transylvania University |
| 1969 | 135 | Bill Bowes | 10 | Elon University |
| 1969 | 149 | Jim Supple | 11 | Georgetown |
| 1969 | 162 | Mike Davis | 12 | Colorado State |
| 1969 | 174 | Ted Johnson | 13 | Baldwin-Wallace College |
| 1968 | 5 | Zaid Abdul-Aziz | 1 | Iowa State |
| 1968 | 27 | Pat Frink | 3 | Colorado |
| 1968 | 28 | Fred Foster | 3 | Miami University |
| 1968 | 41 | Daniel Sparks | 4 | Weber State |
| 1968 | 55 | Jim Kissane | 5 | Boston College |
| 1968 | 69 | Calvin Martin | 6 | Texas Southern |
| 1968 | 83 | Dick Dumas | 7 | Northeastern State University |
| 1968 | 97 | Dave Williams | 8 | Mississippi State |
| 1968 | 111 | Butch Joyner | 9 | Indiana |
| 1968 | 125 | Bo Wyenandt | 10 | Vanderbilt |
| 1968 | 139 | James Robinson | 11 | Rochester Institute of Technology |
| 1968 | 152 | Glynn Saulters | 12 | Louisiana-Monroe |
| 1968 | 165 | Billy Tindall | 13 | UMass |
| 1968 | 176 | Charles Core | 14 | Southeastern Louisiana University |
| 1968 | 185 | Mike Drespling | 15 | Westminster College of Pennsylvania |
| 1968 | 193 | Dick Harris | 16 | Manchester University |
| 1968 | 201 | John Howard | 17 | Cincinnati |
| 1968 | 207 | Larry Humes | 18 | University of Evansville |
| 1968 | 211 | Ray Jeffords | 19 | Georgia |
| 1967 | 9 | Mel Daniels | 1 | New Mexico |
| 1967 | 26 | Gary Gray | 3 | Oklahoma City University |
| 1967 | 28 | Sam Smith | 3 | Kentucky Wesleyan College |
| 1967 | 38 | Louie Dampier | 4 | Kentucky |
| 1967 | 50 | Trooper Washington | 5 | Cheyney (PA) |
| 1967 | 62 | Frank Stronczek | 6 | American International College |
| 1967 | 74 | Charles Beasley | 7 | SMU |
| 1967 | 86 | Frank Hollendoner | 8 | Georgetown |
| 1967 | 97 | Ron Sepic | 9 | Ohio State |
| 1967 | 108 | Willie Davis | 10 | University of North Texas |
| 1967 | 118 | Ken Calloway | 11 | Cincinnati |
| 1967 | 129 | Frank Frank Gaidjunas | 12 | Villanova |
| 1967 | 138 | John Moates | 13 | Richmond |
| 1967 | 144 | Jerry Pettway | 14 | Northwood University |
| 1967 | 150 | Earl Beechum | 15 | Midwestern State University |
| 1967 | 155 | John Vermilyea | 16 | Morningside College |
| 1967 | 158 | Darryl Meachem | 17 | Edinboro University of Pennsylvania |
| 1966 | 6 | Walt Wesley | 1 | Kansas |
| 1966 | 16 | Jerry Lee Wells | 2 | Oklahoma City University |
| 1966 | 26 | Jim Ware | 3 | Oklahoma City University |
| 1966 | 36 | Charles Schmaus | 4 | Virginia Military Institute |
| 1966 | 47 | Richard Parks | 5 | Saint Louis |
| 1966 | 56 | Steve Cunningham | 6 | Western Kentucky |
| 1966 | 65 | Gary Schull | 7 | Florida State |
| 1966 | 74 | Ron Krick | 8 | Cincinnati |
| 1966 | 81 | Billy Smith | 9 | Loyola Chicago |
| 1966 | 88 | Freddie Lewis | 10 | Arizona State |
| 1966 | 95 | R.B. Lynam | 11 | Oklahoma Baptist University |
| 1965 | 9 | Nate Bowman | 1 | Wichita State |
| 1965 | 18 | Flynn Robinson | 2 | Wyoming |
| 1965 | 27 | Jon McGlocklin | 3 | Indiana |
| 1965 | 36 | Bob Love | 4 | Southern University and A&M College |
| 1965 | 45 | Warren Isaac | 5 | Iona College |
| 1965 | 54 | Leon Clements | 6 | Ouachita Baptist University |
| 1965 | 62 | Jeff Gehring | 7 | Miami University |
| 1965 | 70 | Jim Fox | 8 | South Carolina |
| 1965 | 76 | Ron Krick | 9 | Cincinnati |
| 1965 | 82 | Richie Dec | 10 | Seton Hall |
| 1965 | 88 | Dick Maile | 11 | LSU |
| 1965 | 94 | Robert McCollough | 12 | Benedict College |
| 1965 | 99 | Oliver Jones | 13 | Albany State University |
| 1965 | 103 | Larry Franks | 14 | Texas |
| 1965 | 107 | Ronald Scharf | 15 | Georgia Tech |
| 1965 | 111 | Willie Porter | 16 | Tennessee State |
| 1964 | 8 | George Wilson | 1T | Cincinnati |
| 1964 | 17 | Bill Chmielewski | 2 | Dayton |
| 1964 | 26 | Steve Courtin | 3 | Saint Joseph's |
| 1964 | 35 | Happy Hairston | 4 | NYU |
| 1964 | 44 | George Kirk | 5 | Memphis |
| 1964 | 53 | Al Thrasher | 6 | Wittenberg University |
| 1964 | 62 | Vic Rouse | 7 | Loyola Chicago |
| 1964 | 71 | Joe Geiger | 8 | Xavier |
| 1964 | 78 | Scotty Pierce | 9 | West Texas A&M University |
| 1964 | 85 | Bob Neumann | 10 | Memphis |
| 1964 | 91 | Jim Reynolds | 11 | Abilene Christian University |
| 1964 | 95 | Fred Jones | 12 | Youngstown State University |
| 1963 | 5 | Tom Thacker | 1T | Cincinnati |
| 1963 | 23 | Jimmy Rayl | 3 | Indiana |
| 1963 | 32 | Ken Charlton | 4 | Colorado |
| 1963 | 41 | Mack Herndon | 5 | Bradley |
| 1963 | 50 | Jim McCormick | 6 | West Virginia |
| 1963 | 59 | Hunter Beckman | 7 | Memphis |
| 1962 | 6 | Jerry Lucas | 1T | Ohio State |
| 1962 | 15 | Bud Olsen | 2 | Louisville |
| 1962 | 24 | Chris Appel | 3 | USC |
| 1962 | 33 | Jack Thobe | 4 | Xavier |
| 1962 | 42 | Mike Wroblewski | 5 | Kansas State |
| 1962 | 51 | Jerry Foster | 6 | Drake University |
| 1962 | 60 | Gary Cunningham | 7 | UCLA |
| 1962 | 68 | Ed Bento | 8 | Loyola Marymount |
| 1962 | 77 | Chris Jones | 9 | Carson-Newman College |
| 1962 | 85 | George Knighton | 10 | New Mexico State |
| 1962 | 90 | Frank Pinchback | 11 | Xavier |
| 1961 | 3 | Larry Siegfried | 1 | Ohio State |
| 1961 | 16 | Bob Wiesenhahn | 2 | Cincinnati |
| 1961 | 25 | Bevo Nordmann | 3 | Saint Louis |
| 1961 | 34 | Lowery Kirk | 4 | Memphis |
| 1961 | 43 | Rossie Johnson | 5 | Tennessee State |
| 1961 | 52 | Bob Slobodnik | 6 | Duquesne |
| 1961 | 61 | Dave Zeller | 7 | Miami University |
| 1961 | 70 | Gerry Thelen | 8 | Thomas More College |
| 1961 | 78 | Larry Kruger | 9 | Ohio University |
| 1961 | 85 | Jack Waters | 10 | Ole Miss |
| 1961 | 93 | Carl Short | 11 | Newberry College |
| 1961 | 100 | George Patterson | 12 | Toledo |
| 1961 | 103 | Clair McRoberts | 13 | Monmouth University |
| 1961 | 106 | Carl Bouldin | 14 | Cincinnati |
| 1960 | 1 | Oscar Robertson | 1T | Cincinnati |
| 1960 | 9 | Jay Arnette | 2 | Texas |
| 1960 | 17 | Ralph Davis | 3 | Cincinnati |
| 1960 | 25 | Dalen Showalter | 4 | Tennessee |
| 1960 | 33 | Don Ogorek | 5 | Seattle University |
| 1960 | 41 | Bobby Joe Mason | 6 | Bradley |
| 1960 | 49 | Frank Sobrero | 7 | Santa Clara |
| 1960 | 56 | Sam Stith | 8 | St. Bonaventure |
| 1960 | 63 | Al Nealey | 9 | Arizona State |
| 1960 | 70 | Lon Sizemore | 10 | West Virginia Tech |
| 1960 | 75 | Dennis Boone | 11 | Regis University |
| 1960 | 80 | Ron Altenberg | 12 | Cornell College |
| 1960 | 85 | John Milhoan | 13 | Marshall |
| 1960 | 89 | Larry Chanay | 14 | Montana State |
| 1960 | 91 | Ducky Potter | 15 | Moravian College |
| 1960 | 93 | Gene Jordan | 16 | Northwest Missouri State University |
| 1960 | 95 | Ernie McCray | 17 | Arizona |
| 1960 | 97 | Don Mills | 18 | Kentucky |
| 1960 | 99 | Larry Willey | 19 | Cincinnati |
| 1960 | 100 | Tony Wilcox | 20 | Wittenberg University |
| 1960 | 101 | Jim McDonald | 21 | West Virginia Wesleyan College |
| 1959 | 1 | Bob Boozer | 1 | Kansas State |
| 1959 | 17 | Mike Mendenhall | 3 | Cincinnati |
| 1959 | 25 | Leo Byrd | 4 | Marshall |
| 1959 | 33 | Harry Kirchner | 5 | TCU |
| 1959 | 41 | Don Hennon | 6 | Pitt |
| 1959 | 49 | Dale Moore | 7 | Eastern Kentucky University |
| 1959 | 56 | Don Matuszak | 8 | Kansas State |
| 1959 | 62 | Joe Billy McDade | 9 | Bradley |
| 1959 | 68 | Joe Viviano | 10 | Xavier |
| 1959 | 74 | Charley Brown | 11 | Seattle University |
| 1959 | 80 | Roger Wendel | 12 | Tulsa |
| 1958 | 2 | Archie Dees | 1 | Indiana |
| 1958 | 10 | Vern Hatton | 2 | Kentucky |
| 1958 | 18 | Bucky Bockhorn | 3 | Dayton |
| 1958 | 26 | Phil Murrell | 4 | Drake University |
| 1958 | 34 | Jim Fulmer | 5 | Alabama |
| 1958 | 42 | Jim McClellan | 6 | Saint Francis University |
| 1958 | 50 | Wayne Stevens | 7 | Cincinnati |
| 1958 | 58 | Bob Mantz | 8 | Lafayette College |
| 1958 | 65 | Larry Staverman | 9 | Thomas More College |
| 1958 | 71 | Jack Parr | 10 | Kansas State |
| 1958 | 76 | Frank Tartaron | 11 | Xavier |
| 1958 | 80 | Don Medsker | 12 | Iowa State |
| 1958 | 84 | Jerry DuPont | 13 | Louisville |
| 1958 | 85 | Jim Newcome | 14 | Duke |
| 1958 | 86 | Adrian Smith | 15 | Kentucky |
| 1958 | 87 | Jack McCarthy | 16 | Dayton |
| 1958 | 88 | John Powell | 17 | Miami University |
| 1957 | 1 | Hot Rod Hundley (↳MNL) | 1 | West Virginia |
| 1957 | 9 | Dick Duckett | 2 | St. John's |
| 1957 | 17 | Jerry Paulson | 3 | Manhattan University |
| 1957 | 25 | Jed Dommeyer | 4 | Minnesota |
| 1957 | 33 | Stuart Murray | 5 | Lafayette College |
| 1957 | 41 | John Maglio | 6 | NC State |
| 1957 | 49 | Chet Forte | 7 | Columbia University |
| 1957 | 56 | Bob Daniels | 8 | Western Kentucky |
| 1957 | 63 | Dick Heise | 9 | DePaul |
| 1957 | 70 | Mel Wright | 10 | Oklahoma State |
| 1957 | 76 | Cliff Hafer | 11 | NC State |
| 1957 | 80 | Jim Boothe | 12 | Xavier |
| 1956 | 1 | Si Green | 1 | Duquesne |
| 1956 | 9 | Bob Burrow | 2 | Kentucky |
| 1956 | 17 | Dave Piontek | 3 | Xavier |
| 1956 | 25 | Johnny McCarthy | 4 | Canisius |
| 1956 | 33 | Bill Uhl | 5 | Dayton |
| 1956 | 41 | Kevin Thomas | 6 | Boston University |
| 1956 | 49 | Carl Cain | 7 | Iowa |
| 1956 | 57 | Clayton Carter | 8 | Oklahoma State |
| 1956 | 64 | Dan Mannix | 9 | St. Francis College |
| 1956 | 71 | Jerry Moreman | 10 | Louisville |
| 1956 | 77 | Gene Carpenter | 11 | Texas Tech |
| 1955 | 2 | Maurice Stokes | 1 | Saint Francis University |
| 1955 | 10 | Jack Twyman | 2 | Cincinnati |
| 1955 | 18 | Ed Fleming | 3 | Niagara University |
| 1955 | 26 | Bob McKeen | 4 | California |
| 1955 | 34 | Bill Evans | 5 | Kentucky |
| 1955 | 42 | Bob Armstrong | 6 | Michigan State |
| 1955 | 50 | Jim McConnell | 7 | Niagara University |
| 1955 | 58 | Tony Vlastelica | 8 | Oregon State |
| 1955 | 66 | Jerry Jung | 9 | Kansas State |
| 1955 | 74 | Harry Jorgensen | 10 | Wyoming |
| 1955 | 82 | Art Quimby | 11 | UConn |
| 1955 | 89 | John Prudhoe | 12 | Louisville |
| 1954 | 7 | Tom Marshall | 1 | Western Kentucky |
| 1954 | 16 | Boris Nachamkin | 2 | NYU |
| 1954 | 25 | Lee Morton | 3 | Cornell |
| 1954 | 34 | Art Spoelstra | 4 | Western Kentucky |
| 1954 | 43 | Bo Erias | 5 | Niagara University |
| 1954 | 52 | Red Davis | 6 | St. John's |
| 1954 | 61 | Bill Hull | 7 | Utah State University |
| 1954 | 70 | Paul Morrow | 8 | Wisconsin |
| 1954 | 78 | Roy Irvin | 9 | USC |
| 1954 | 87 | Ed Parchinski | 10 | Fordham |
| 1954 | 95 | Jim Paxson | 11 | Dayton |
| 1953 | 5 | Richie Regan | 1 | Seton Hall |
| 1953 | 14 | Norm Swanson | 2 | Detroit Mercy |
| 1952 | 9 | Chuck Darling | 1 | Iowa |
| 1951 | 8 | Sam Ranzino | 1 | NC State |
| 1951 | 18 | Ray Ragelis | 2 | Northwestern |
| 1951 | 28 | Fred Diute | 3 | St. Bonaventure |
| 1951 | 38 | Elmer Behnke | 4 | Bradley |
| 1951 | 48 | Dan Bagley | 5 | Notre Dame |
| 1951 | 58 | Jim Ove | 6 | Valparaiso |
| 1951 | 68 | Jack Brown | 7 | SMU |
| 1951 | 77 | George Davidson | 8 | Lafayette College |
| 1950 | 10 | Joe McNamee | 1 | San Francisco |
| 1950 | 22 | George Stanich | 2 | UCLA |
| 1950 | 34 | Bob Roper | 3 | John Carroll University |
| 1950 | 46 | Chet Giermak | 4 | William & Mary |
| 1950 | 58 | Joe Nelson | 5 | BYU |
| 1950 | 70 | John Givens | 6 | Western Kentucky |
| 1950 | 82 | Dan Kahler | 7 | Southwestern College |
| 1950 | 94 | Carl Kraushaar | 8 | UCLA |
| 1950 | 106 | Warren Switzer | 9 | Rice University |
| 1950 | 116 | Henry Foley | 10 | Niagara University |
| 1949 | 12 | Pep Saul | 1 | Seton Hall |
| 1949 | 24 | Jack Coleman | 2 | Louisville |
| 1948 | 10 | Bobby Wanzer | 1 | Seton Hall |
