| 2025 | 50 | Kobe Sanders (↳LAC) | 2 | Nevada |
| 2024 | 24 | Kyshawn George (↳WAS) | 1 | Miami (FL) |
| 2024 | 25 | Pacôme Dadiet | 1 | |
| 2024 | 38 | Ajay Mitchell (↳OKC) | 2 | UC Santa Barbara |
| 2024 | 51 | Melvin Ajinça (↳DAL) | 2 | |
| 2022 | 11 | Ousmane Dieng (↳OKC) | 1 | |
| 2022 | 42 | Trevor Keels | 2 | Duke |
| 2021 | 19 | Kai Jones (↳CHO) | 1 | Texas |
| 2021 | 21 | Keon Johnson (↳LAC) | 1 | Tennessee |
| 2021 | 32 | Jeremiah Robinson-Earl (↳OKC) | 2 | Villanova |
| 2021 | 58 | Jericho Sims | 2 | Texas |
| 2020 | 8 | Obi Toppin | 1 | Dayton |
| 2020 | 23 | Leandro Bolmaro (↳MIN) | 1 | |
| 2019 | 3 | RJ Barrett | 1 | Duke |
| 2019 | 55 | Kyle Guy (↳SAC) | 2 | Virginia |
| 2018 | 9 | Kevin Knox | 1 | Kentucky |
| 2018 | 36 | Mitchell Robinson | 2 | |
| 2017 | 8 | Frank Ntilikina | 1 | |
| 2017 | 44 | Damyean Dotson | 2 | Oregon |
| 2017 | 58 | Ognjen Jaramaz | 2 | |
| 2015 | 4 | Kristaps Porziņģis | 1 | |
| 2014 | 34 | Cleanthony Early | 2 | Wichita State |
| 2014 | 51 | Thanasis Antetokounmpo | 2 | |
| 2013 | 24 | Tim Hardaway | 1 | Michigan |
| 2012 | 48 | Kostas Papanikolaou (↳POR) | 2 | |
| 2011 | 17 | Iman Shumpert | 1 | Georgia Tech |
| 2010 | 38 | Andy Rautins | 2 | Syracuse |
| 2010 | 39 | Landry Fields | 2 | Stanford |
| 2009 | 8 | Jordan Hill | 1 | Arizona |
| 2008 | 6 | Danilo Gallinari | 1 | |
| 2007 | 23 | Wilson Chandler | 1 | DePaul |
| 2006 | 20 | Renaldo Balkman | 1 | South Carolina |
| 2006 | 29 | Mardy Collins | 1 | Temple |
| 2005 | 8 | Channing Frye | 1 | Arizona |
| 2005 | 30 | David Lee | 1 | Florida |
| 2005 | 54 | Dijon Thompson (↳PHO) | 2 | UCLA |
| 2004 | 43 | Trevor Ariza | 2 | UCLA |
| 2003 | 9 | Mike Sweetney | 1 | Georgetown |
| 2003 | 30 | Maciej Lampe | 2 | |
| 2003 | 39 | Slavko Vraneš | 2 | |
| 2002 | 7 | Nenê Hilário (↳DEN) | 1 | |
| 2002 | 36 | Milos Vujanic | 2 | |
| 2001 | 39 | Michael Wright | 2 | Arizona |
| 2001 | 43 | Eric Chenowith | 2 | Kansas |
| 2000 | 22 | Donnell Harvey (↳DAL) | 1 | Florida |
| 2000 | 39 | Lavor Postell | 2 | St. John's |
| 1999 | 15 | Frédéric Weis | 1 | |
| 1999 | 46 | J.R. Koch | 2 | Iowa |
| 1998 | 38 | DeMarco Johnson | 2 | UNC Charlotte |
| 1998 | 44 | Sean Marks (↳TOR) | 2 | California |
| 1997 | 25 | John Thomas (↳BOS) | 1 | Minnesota |
| 1996 | 18 | John Wallace | 1 | Syracuse |
| 1996 | 19 | Walter McCarty | 1 | Kentucky |
| 1996 | 21 | Dontae' Jones | 1 | Mississippi State |
| 1994 | 24 | Monty Williams | 1 | Notre Dame |
| 1994 | 26 | Charlie Ward | 1 | Florida State |
| 1992 | 20 | Hubert Davis | 1 | UNC |
| 1991 | 12 | Greg Anthony | 1 | UNLV |
| 1990 | 17 | Jerrod Mustaf | 1 | Maryland |
| 1989 | 50 | Brian Quinnett | 2 | Washington State |
| 1988 | 19 | Rod Strickland | 1 | DePaul |
| 1988 | 37 | Greg Butler | 2 | Stanford |
| 1988 | 69 | Phil Stinnie | 3 | VCU |
| 1987 | 18 | Mark Jackson | 1 | St. John's |
| 1987 | 25 | Ron Moore (↳DET) | 2 | West Virginia State University |
| 1987 | 49 | Jerome Batiste | 3 | McNeese State University |
| 1987 | 71 | Mike Morgan | 4 | Drake University |
| 1987 | 95 | Glen Clem | 5 | Vanderbilt |
| 1987 | 117 | Howard Triche | 6 | Syracuse |
| 1987 | 141 | Wayne Williams | 7 | Saint Joseph's |
| 1986 | 5 | Kenny Walker | 1 | Kentucky |
| 1986 | 47 | Michael Jackson | 2 | Georgetown |
| 1986 | 71 | Calvin Thompson | 4 | Kansas |
| 1986 | 94 | Jerome Mincey | 5 | UAB |
| 1986 | 117 | Butch Wade | 6 | Michigan |
| 1986 | 140 | Duane Kendall | 7 | South Carolina |
| 1985 | 1 | Patrick Ewing | 1 | Georgetown |
| 1985 | 47 | Gerald Wilkins | 2 | Chattanooga |
| 1985 | 73 | Fred Cofield | 4 | Eastern Michigan |
| 1985 | 96 | Mike Schlegel | 5 | VCU |
| 1985 | 119 | Kent Lockhart | 6 | Texas-El Paso |
| 1985 | 142 | Ken Bantum | 7 | Cornell |
| 1984 | 64 | Curtis Green | 3 | Southern Miss |
| 1984 | 87 | Bob Thornton | 4 | University of California, Irvine |
| 1984 | 133 | Eddie Lee Wilkins | 6 | Gardner-Webb University |
| 1984 | 156 | Ken Bannister | 7 | Saint Augustine's College |
| 1984 | 179 | Ricky Tunstall | 8 | Youngstown State University |
| 1984 | 201 | Marc Marotta | 9 | Marquette |
| 1984 | 223 | Mike Henderson | 10 | LIU Post |
| 1983 | 12 | Darrell Walker | 1 | Arkansas |
| 1983 | 82 | Mark Jones | 4 | St. Bonaventure |
| 1983 | 105 | Troy Lee Mikell | 5 | East Tennessee State University |
| 1983 | 128 | Tony Simms | 6 | Boston University |
| 1983 | 151 | Desi Barmore | 7 | Fresno State |
| 1983 | 174 | Mike Lang | 8 | Penn State |
| 1983 | 196 | Charles Jones | 9 | Marshall |
| 1983 | 217 | Bernard Randolph | 10 | DePaul |
| 1982 | 6 | Trent Tucker | 1 | Minnesota |
| 1982 | 29 | Scott Hastings | 2 | Arkansas |
| 1982 | 34 | Vince Taylor | 2 | Duke |
| 1982 | 52 | Dan Caldwell | 3 | Washington |
| 1982 | 57 | Craig Tucker | 3 | Illinois |
| 1982 | 75 | Norm Anchrum | 4 | UAB |
| 1982 | 98 | Aaron Howard | 5 | Villanova |
| 1982 | 121 | Mike Kanieski | 6 | Dayton |
| 1982 | 144 | Phil Seymore | 7 | Canisius |
| 1982 | 167 | Dan Terwilliger | 8 | Siena College |
| 1982 | 190 | Merle Scott | 9 | South Carolina State |
| 1982 | 211 | John Leonard | 10 | Manhattan University |
| 1981 | 40 | Greg Cook | 2 | LSU |
| 1981 | 57 | Frank Brickowski | 3 | Penn State |
| 1981 | 63 | Wayne McKoy | 3 | St. John's |
| 1981 | 86 | Alex Bradley | 4 | Villanova |
| 1981 | 109 | Jim Wright | 5 | Rhode Island |
| 1981 | 132 | John Blair | 6 | Monmouth University |
| 1981 | 155 | Terry Cramer | 7 | Ripon College |
| 1981 | 177 | Brian O'Connor | 8 | Thomas More College |
| 1981 | 198 | Marty Headd | 9 | Syracuse |
| 1981 | 218 | Kevin Rogers | 10 | Saint Peter's College |
| 1980 | 12 | Mike Woodson | 1 | Indiana |
| 1980 | 36 | DeWayne Scales | 2 | LSU |
| 1980 | 58 | Kurt Rambis | 3 | Santa Clara |
| 1980 | 82 | Joseph Chrnelich | 4 | Wisconsin |
| 1980 | 104 | William Carey | 5 | Albright College |
| 1980 | 128 | Kelvin Hicks | 6 | New York Institute of Technology |
| 1980 | 150 | Bobby Turner | 7 | Louisville |
| 1980 | 171 | James Salters | 8 | Penn |
| 1980 | 190 | Don Wiley | 9 | Monmouth University |
| 1980 | 208 | Gerard Ross | 10 | Grand Canyon University |
| 1979 | 3 | Bill Cartwright | 1 | San Francisco |
| 1979 | 9 | Larry Demic | 1 | Arizona |
| 1979 | 21 | Sly Williams | 1 | Rhode Island |
| 1979 | 27 | Reggie Carter | 2 | St. John's |
| 1979 | 34 | Kim Goetz | 2 | San Diego State |
| 1979 | 50 | Geoff Huston | 3 | Texas Tech |
| 1979 | 71 | Larry Rogers | 4 | SE Missouri State |
| 1979 | 94 | Johnny Green | 5 | University of California, Riverside |
| 1979 | 113 | Phil Abney | 6 | New Mexico |
| 1979 | 134 | Marc Coleman | 7 | Seton Hall |
| 1979 | 152 | Billy Tucker | 8 | Tennessee State |
| 1979 | 172 | Brett Wyatt | 9 | New Jersey City University |
| 1979 | 189 | Gordon Thomas | 10 | St. John's |
| 1978 | 4 | Micheal Ray Richardson | 1 | Montana |
| 1978 | 32 | John Rudd | 2 | McNeese State University |
| 1978 | 34 | Greg Bunch | 2 | Cal State Fullerton |
| 1978 | 55 | Marc Iavaroni | 3 | Virginia |
| 1978 | 79 | Erving Giddings | 4 | Dayton |
| 1978 | 100 | Greg Green | 5 | Southern University and A&M College |
| 1978 | 121 | Eddie Warren | 6 | Briar Cliff University |
| 1978 | 144 | Gary Pember | 7 | Nasson College |
| 1978 | 162 | Greg Sanders | 8 | St. Bonaventure |
| 1978 | 178 | Denny Fields | 9 | UNC Wilmington |
| 1978 | 195 | Ernest Simons | 10 | Pace University |
| 1977 | 10 | Ray Williams | 1 | Minnesota |
| 1977 | 26 | Glen Gondrezick | 2 | UNLV |
| 1977 | 32 | Toby Knight | 2 | Notre Dame |
| 1977 | 54 | Lloyd McMillian | 3 | Cal State Long Beach |
| 1977 | 76 | Steve Hayes | 4 | Idaho State University |
| 1977 | 98 | Bill Terry | 5 | Monmouth University |
| 1977 | 120 | Jerry Craycraft | 6 | Milligan College |
| 1977 | 140 | Tom Weadock | 7 | St. John's |
| 1977 | 159 | Ken Slappy | 8 | Saint Peter's College |
| 1976 | 25 | Lonnie Shelton | 2 | Oregon State |
| 1976 | 41 | John McGill | 3 | Alcorn State |
| 1976 | 57 | Rick Bullock | 4 | Texas Tech |
| 1976 | 76 | Beaver Smith | 5 | St. John's |
| 1976 | 93 | Joe Jones | 6 | Grambling State University |
| 1976 | 110 | Boyd Batts | 7 | UNLV |
| 1976 | 130 | Rick McCutcheon | 8 | Arizona State |
| 1976 | 147 | Archie Talley | 9 | Salem University |
| 1976 | 163 | Gene Shy | 10 | Florida |
| 1975 | 9 | Gene Short | 1 | Jackson State University |
| 1975 | 26 | Ticky Burden | 2 | Utah |
| 1975 | 34 | Larry Fogle | 2 | Canisius |
| 1975 | 46 | John Ramsay | 3 | Seton Hall |
| 1975 | 63 | David Vaughn | 4 | Oral Roberts |
| 1975 | 80 | Donald Washington | 5 | UNC |
| 1975 | 100 | Hank Williams | 6 | Jacksonville University |
| 1975 | 117 | Pete Davis | 7 | Michigan State |
| 1975 | 134 | Jerry Homan | 8 | Marquette |
| 1975 | 153 | Tim van Blommesteyn (↳MMS) | 9 | Princeton |
| 1975 | 168 | Moe Rivers | 10 | NC State |
| 1974 | 32 | Jesse Dark | 2 | VCU |
| 1974 | 50 | Rudy Jackson | 3 | Hutchinson Community College |
| 1974 | 68 | Roy Ebron | 4 | Louisiana |
| 1974 | 86 | Greg Jackson | 5 | Guilford College |
| 1974 | 104 | Terry Mikan | 6 | St. Thomas University |
| 1974 | 122 | Billy Smith | 7 | Mercer University |
| 1974 | 140 | Dennis McDermott | 8 | St. Francis College |
| 1974 | 157 | Earl Brown | 9 | Lafayette College |
| 1974 | 174 | John O'Donnell | 10 | UNC |
| 1973 | 14 | Mel Davis | 1 | St. John's |
| 1973 | 28 | Patrick McFarland | 2 | Saint Joseph's |
| 1973 | 49 | Allie McGuire | 3 | Marquette |
| 1973 | 66 | George Karl | 4 | UNC |
| 1973 | 83 | Dennis Bell | 5 | Drake University |
| 1973 | 100 | Lawrence Lilly | 6 | Alabama State University |
| 1973 | 117 | Mike Moore | 7 | Manhattan University |
| 1973 | 134 | Steve Rowell | 8 | Rhode Island |
| 1973 | 149 | Joe Wise | 9 | Bridgewater State College |
| 1973 | 163 | Ed Fields | 10 | LIU Post |
| 1973 | 173 | Charles Edge | 11 | LeMoyne-Owen College |
| 1972 | 8 | Tom Riker | 1 | South Carolina |
| 1972 | 41 | Ansley Truitt | 3 | California |
| 1972 | 58 | Henry Bibby | 4 | UCLA |
| 1972 | 74 | Bob Ford | 5 | Purdue |
| 1972 | 91 | Greg Cluess | 6 | St. John's |
| 1972 | 108 | Tracy Tripucka | 7 | Lafayette College |
| 1972 | 124 | Tom Corde | 8 | Ohio University |
| 1972 | 139 | Tom Sullivan | 9 | Fordham |
| 1972 | 152 | Richie Garner | 10 | Manhattan University |
| 1972 | 163 | Chic Downing | 11 | Benedictine College |
| 1971 | 16 | Dean Meminger | 1 | Marquette |
| 1971 | 34 | Gregg Northington | 2 | Alabama State University |
| 1971 | 50 | Ken Mayfield | 3 | Tuskegee University |
| 1971 | 67 | Steve Niles | 4 | Texas A&M |
| 1971 | 101 | Bill Mainor | 6 | Fordham |
| 1971 | 118 | Danny Davis | 7 | Henderson State University |
| 1971 | 135 | Leroy Eldridge | 8 | Cheyney (PA) |
| 1971 | 151 | Mike O'Brien | 9 | Saint Leo University |
| 1971 | 167 | Andy Toth | 10 | Cheyney (PA) |
| 1971 | 181 | Ken Davis | 11 | Georgetown College |
| 1971 | 194 | Carl Greenfield | 12 | Eastern Kentucky University |
| 1971 | 206 | Larry Duckworth | 13 | Henderson State University |
| 1971 | 215 | Jack O'Connor | 14 | University of Great Falls |
| 1970 | 17 | Mike Price | 1 | Illinois |
| 1970 | 34 | Howie Wright | 2 | Austin Peay State University |
| 1970 | 51 | Al Williams | 3 | Drake University |
| 1970 | 68 | John Marren | 4 | Manhattan University |
| 1970 | 85 | Jim Oxley | 5 | United States Military Academy |
| 1970 | 102 | Jim Signorile | 6 | NYU |
| 1970 | 119 | Ray Hodge | 7 | Wagner College |
| 1970 | 136 | Greg Fillmore | 8 | Cheyney (PA) |
| 1970 | 153 | Walker Banks | 9 | Western Kentucky |
| 1970 | 170 | Don Curnutt | 10 | Miami (FL) |
| 1969 | 11 | John Warren | 1 | St. John's |
| 1969 | 26 | Bill Bunting (↳CAR) | 2 | UNC |
| 1969 | 40 | Eddie Mast | 3 | Temple |
| 1969 | 54 | Elnardo Webster | 4 | Saint Peter's College |
| 1969 | 68 | Gene Littles | 5 | High Point University |
| 1969 | 82 | Dwight Durante | 6 | Catawba College |
| 1969 | 96 | Chris Thomforde | 7 | Princeton |
| 1969 | 110 | Jim Healey | 8 | Rockhurst University |
| 1969 | 124 | Roger Walaszek | 9 | Columbia University |
| 1969 | 138 | Frank McLaughlin | 10 | Fordham |
| 1969 | 152 | Marvin Lewis | 11 | LIU Southampton |
| 1969 | 165 | Bill O'Rourke | 12 | St. John Fisher College |
| 1969 | 177 | James Wyatt | 13 | Northwestern State University |
| 1969 | 186 | Rich Travis | 14 | Oklahoma City University |
| 1968 | 10 | Bill Hosket | 1 | Ohio State |
| 1968 | 30 | Don May | 3 | Dayton |
| 1968 | 44 | Warren Jabali | 4 | Wichita State |
| 1968 | 58 | Hal Booker | 5 | Cheyney (PA) |
| 1968 | 72 | Brian Brunkhorst | 6 | Marquette |
| 1968 | 86 | Bob Waldal | 7 | Dickinson State University |
| 1968 | 100 | Bobby Hooper | 8 | Dayton |
| 1968 | 114 | Rodger Bohnenstiehl | 9 | Kansas |
| 1968 | 128 | Sylvester Adams | 10 | North Carolina A&T |
| 1968 | 141 | Bob Redd | 11 | Marshall |
| 1968 | 154 | Pat Moriarty | 12 | Guilford College |
| 1968 | 166 | Ken Morehead | 13 | Hillsdale College |
| 1968 | 177 | John Haarlow | 14 | Princeton |
| 1968 | 186 | Ed Fellers | 15 | Guilford College |
| 1968 | 194 | Bob Ferguson | 16 | Tennessee Wesleyan College |
| 1968 | 202 | Milt Williams | 17 | Lincoln University of Missouri |
| 1967 | 5 | Walt Frazier | 1 | Southern Illinois |
| 1967 | 17 | Phil Jackson | 2 | University of North Dakota |
| 1967 | 24 | Gary Gregor | 3 | South Carolina |
| 1967 | 36 | Keith Swagerty | 4 | University of the Pacific |
| 1967 | 48 | Barry Leibowitz | 5 | Long Island University |
| 1967 | 60 | Bob Benfield | 6 | West Virginia |
| 1967 | 72 | Butch Wade | 7 | Indiana State University |
| 1967 | 84 | Gil Radday | 8 | St. Francis College |
| 1967 | 95 | Roy Smith | 9 | Kansas State |
| 1967 | 106 | Bruce Kaplan | 10 | NYU |
| 1967 | 117 | Mark Mirken | 11 | UNC |
| 1967 | 128 | Mike Riordan | 12 | Providence |
| 1966 | 1 | Cazzie Russell | 1 | Michigan |
| 1966 | 11 | Henry Akin | 2 | Morehead State University |
| 1966 | 21 | Stew Johnson | 3 | Murray State |
| 1966 | 31 | Lee DeFore | 4 | Auburn |
| 1966 | 41 | Ron Jackson | 5 | Clark Atlanta University |
| 1966 | 51 | George Fisher | 6 | Utah |
| 1966 | 60 | Mike Dabich | 7 | New Mexico State |
| 1966 | 69 | Mike Silliman | 8 | United States Military Academy |
| 1966 | 78 | Bill Turner | 9 | University of Akron |
| 1966 | 85 | Richard Moore | 10 | Hiram Scott College |
| 1966 | 92 | Rich Dyer | 11 | NYU |
| 1966 | 98 | Dave Deutsch | 12 | University of Rochester |
| 1966 | 101 | Bob Bennett | 13 | UNC |
| 1965 | 2 | Bill Bradley | 1T | Princeton |
| 1965 | 5 | Dave Stallworth | 1 | Wichita State |
| 1965 | 13 | Dick Van Arsdale | 2 | Indiana |
| 1965 | 17 | Hal Blevins | 2 | University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff |
| 1965 | 22 | Barry Clemens | 3 | Ohio Wesleyan University |
| 1965 | 31 | Larry Lembo | 4 | Manhattan University |
| 1965 | 40 | Steve Nisenson | 5 | Hofstra |
| 1965 | 49 | Warren Davis | 6 | North Carolina A&T |
| 1965 | 58 | Dale Neel | 7 | High Point University |
| 1965 | 66 | Frank Granat | 8 | Alliance College |
| 1965 | 72 | Jay Neary | 9 | UNC Wilmington |
| 1965 | 78 | Wayne Molis | 10 | Lewis (IL) |
| 1965 | 84 | Bill Meyer | 11 | Hiram College |
| 1965 | 90 | Bob Trupin | 12 | Yale |
| 1965 | 95 | Dennis McGovern | 13 | Rhode Island |
| 1964 | 1 | Jim Barnes | 1 | Texas-El Paso |
| 1964 | 10 | Willis Reed | 2 | Grambling State University |
| 1964 | 15 | Howard Komives | 2 | Bowling Green |
| 1964 | 19 | Brian Generalovich | 3 | Pitt |
| 1964 | 28 | Freddie Crawford | 4 | St. Bonaventure |
| 1964 | 37 | Tony Gennari | 5 | Canisius |
| 1964 | 46 | Tom Lavelle | 6 | Western Carolina University |
| 1964 | 55 | Em Bryant | 7 | DePaul |
| 1964 | 64 | Jim Boutin | 8 | Lewis and Clark College |
| 1964 | 73 | Jack Brens | 9 | Wisconsin |
| 1964 | 80 | Jim Christy | 10 | Georgetown |
| 1964 | 87 | Dennis Lynch | 11 | Yale |
| 1963 | 1 | Art Heyman | 1 | Duke |
| 1963 | 10 | Jerry Harkness | 2 | Loyola Chicago |
| 1963 | 19 | Bill O'Connor | 3 | Canisius |
| 1963 | 28 | Nate Cloud | 4 | University of Delaware |
| 1963 | 37 | Joe McDermott | 5 | Belmont Abbey College |
| 1963 | 46 | Jim Kerwin | 6 | Tulane |
| 1963 | 55 | Bob Woolard | 7 | Wake Forest |
| 1963 | 64 | Freddie Crawford | 8 | St. Bonaventure |
| 1963 | 69 | Ray Cronk | 9 | Lakeland College |
| 1963 | 74 | Gerald Glur | 10 | Furman University |
| 1963 | 77 | Orbie Bowling | 11 | Tennessee |
| 1963 | 79 | Bob Walters | 12 | Baldwin-Wallace College |
| 1963 | 81 | Jerry Szachara | 13 | Cornell |
| 1963 | 83 | Bill Raftery | 14 | La Salle |
| 1963 | 84 | Ron Pickett | 15 | Eastern Kentucky University |
| 1962 | 2 | Paul Hogue | 1 | Cincinnati |
| 1962 | 11 | John Rudometkin | 2 | USC |
| 1962 | 20 | Bobby Rascoe | 3 | Western Kentucky |
| 1962 | 29 | Cliff Luyk (↳CHZ) | 4 | Florida |
| 1962 | 38 | Bob Burgess | 5 | Marshall |
| 1962 | 47 | Ken Stanley | 6 | University of the Pacific |
| 1962 | 56 | Richie Swartz | 7 | Hofstra |
| 1962 | 64 | Warren Fouts | 8 | Oklahoma |
| 1962 | 73 | Paul Benec | 9 | Duquesne |
| 1962 | 82 | Ralph Richardson | 10 | Eastern Kentucky University |
| 1962 | 88 | Ed Mazria | 11 | Pratt Institute |
| 1961 | 2 | Tom Stith | 1 | St. Bonaventure |
| 1961 | 15 | Whitey Martin | 2 | St. Bonaventure |
| 1961 | 24 | Tony Jackson | 3 | St. John's |
| 1961 | 33 | George Blaney | 4 | Holy Cross |
| 1961 | 42 | Bill Smith | 5 | Saint Peter's College |
| 1961 | 51 | Cleveland Buckner | 6 | Jackson State University |
| 1961 | 60 | Donnie Butcher | 7 | Pikeville College |
| 1961 | 69 | Cedric Price | 8 | Kansas State |
| 1961 | 77 | Charlie Bowerman | 9 | Wabash College |
| 1961 | 84 | Ron Dibelius | 10 | UW-Milwaukee |
| 1961 | 92 | Kevin Loughery | 11 | St. John's |
| 1961 | 99 | Earl Shultz | 12 | California |
| 1961 | 102 | Ned Jennings | 13 | Kentucky |
| 1961 | 105 | Bill Engesser | 14 | USC |
| 1961 | 107 | Vince Kempton | 15 | Saint Joseph's |
| 1960 | 3 | Darrall Imhoff | 1 | California |
| 1960 | 10 | Dave Budd | 2 | Wake Forest |
| 1960 | 11 | Kelly Coleman | 2 | Kentucky Wesleyan College |
| 1960 | 19 | Bob McNeill | 3 | Saint Joseph's |
| 1960 | 35 | Charles McNeil | 5 | Maryland |
| 1960 | 43 | David Denton | 6 | Georgia Tech |
| 1960 | 51 | Dick Doughty | 7 | California |
| 1960 | 58 | George Price | 8 | Memphis |
| 1960 | 65 | Tony Davis | 9 | Hawaii |
| 1960 | 72 | Walter Mangham | 10 | Marquette |
| 1960 | 77 | Howard Willis | 11 | Grambling State University |
| 1960 | 82 | Henry Hart | 12 | Auburn |
| 1960 | 86 | Dick Furry | 13 | Ohio State |
| 1960 | 90 | Jim Hanna | 14 | USC |
| 1960 | 92 | Jerry Bechtle | 15 | Maryland |
| 1960 | 94 | Jerry Schofield | 16 | Utah State University |
| 1960 | 96 | Tandy Gillis | 17 | California |
| 1960 | 98 | George Krajack | 18 | Clemson |
| 1959 | 6 | Johnny Green | 1 | Michigan State |
| 1959 | 22 | Bob Anderegg | 3 | Michigan State |
| 1959 | 30 | Johnny Cox | 4 | Kentucky |
| 1959 | 38 | Herb Busch | 5 | Virginia |
| 1959 | 46 | Bucky McDonald | 6 | George Washington |
| 1959 | 54 | Russ Robinson | 7 | Missouri State |
| 1959 | 60 | Walt Torrence | 8 | UCLA |
| 1959 | 66 | Jerry Shipp | 9 | Southeastern Oklahoma State University |
| 1959 | 72 | Paul Wilcox | 10 | Davis & Elkins College |
| 1959 | 78 | Paul Benes | 11 | Hope College |
| 1959 | 82 | Ed Blair | 12 | Western Michigan |
| 1959 | 84 | John Nicoll | 13 | BYU |
| 1959 | 85 | Jack Israel | 14 | Missouri State |
| 1958 | 3 | Mike Farmer | 1 | San Francisco |
| 1958 | 4 | Pete Brennan | 1 | UNC |
| 1958 | 12 | Joe Quigg | 2 | UNC |
| 1958 | 20 | John Lee | 3 | Yale |
| 1958 | 28 | Johnny Cox | 4 | Kentucky |
| 1958 | 36 | Don Lane | 5 | Dayton |
| 1958 | 44 | Joe King | 6 | Oklahoma |
| 1958 | 52 | Owen Lawson | 7 | Western Kentucky |
| 1958 | 60 | Milt Kane | 8 | Utah |
| 1958 | 67 | John McCarthy | 9 | Notre Dame |
| 1957 | 5 | Brendan McCann | 1 | St. Bonaventure |
| 1957 | 13 | Larry Friend | 2 | California |
| 1957 | 21 | Gary Clark | 3 | Syracuse |
| 1957 | 29 | Rayford Wells | 4 | Lenoir-Rhyne College |
| 1957 | 37 | Lee Marshall | 5 | Washington & Lee University |
| 1957 | 45 | Jim Humphrey | 6 | Saint Michael's College |
| 1956 | 4 | Ron Shavlik | 1 | NC State |
| 1956 | 12 | Gary Bergen | 2 | Utah |
| 1956 | 20 | Jerry Harper | 3 | Alabama |
| 1956 | 28 | Ronnie Mayer | 4 | Duke |
| 1956 | 36 | Joe Sexson | 5 | Purdue |
| 1956 | 44 | Pat Dunn | 6 | Utah State University |
| 1956 | 52 | Jack Adams | 7 | Eastern Kentucky University |
| 1956 | 60 | Art Bunte | 8 | Utah |
| 1956 | 67 | Dick Miller | 9 | Wisconsin |
| 1956 | 74 | Howard Crittenden | 10 | Murray State |
| 1956 | 80 | Dick Miani | 11 | Miami (FL) |
| 1956 | 84 | Ed Petrie | 12 | Seton Hall |
| 1956 | 88 | Toby Roybal | 13 | New Mexico |
| 1955 | 5 | Kenny Sears | 1 | Santa Clara |
| 1955 | 13 | Jerry Mullen | 2 | San Francisco |
| 1955 | 21 | Guy Sparrow | 3 | Detroit Mercy |
| 1955 | 29 | Ed Cole | 4 | Creighton |
| 1955 | 37 | Denver Brackeen | 5 | Ole Miss |
| 1955 | 45 | Howard Sessums | 6 | Mississippi College |
| 1955 | 53 | Jim Fay | 7 | St. Ambrose University |
| 1955 | 61 | Jack Beck | 8 | Truman State University |
| 1955 | 69 | Don Payne | 9 | Adelphi University |
| 1955 | 77 | Wally McCarvill | 10 | Iona College |
| 1955 | 84 | Charles Stickels | 11 | Hastings College |
| 1955 | 91 | Mickey Harrington | 12 | Southern Miss |
| 1954 | 8 | Jack Turner | 1 | Western Kentucky |
| 1954 | 17 | Richie Guerin | 2 | Iona College |
| 1954 | 26 | Don Anielak | 3 | Missouri State |
| 1954 | 35 | Don Lange | 4 | United States Naval Academy |
| 1954 | 44 | Jesse Priscock | 5 | Kansas State |
| 1954 | 53 | Ron Rivers | 6 | Wyoming |
| 1954 | 62 | Solly Walker | 7 | St. John's |
| 1954 | 71 | Cob Jarvis | 8 | Mississippi State |
| 1954 | 79 | Henry Duckham | 9 | Polytechnic University |
| 1954 | 88 | John Clune | 10 | United States Naval Academy |
| 1954 | 96 | Bob Waller | 11 | Oklahoma |
| 1954 | 99 | Charles Stickels | 12 | Hastings College |
| 1953 | 8 | Walter Dukes | 1T | Seton Hall |
| 1953 | 11 | Don Ackerman | 2 | Long Island University |
| 1953 | 17 | Neil Gordon | 2 | Furman University |
| 1952 | 6 | Ralph Polson | 1 | Whitworth |
| 1951 | 6 | Ed Smith | 1 | Harvard University |
| 1951 | 16 | Roland Minson | 2 | BYU |
| 1951 | 26 | Joe Luchi | 3 | Cincinnati |
| 1951 | 36 | Lloyd Sandstrom | 4 | University of St. Thomas |
| 1951 | 46 | Tom Smith | 5 | Saint Peter's College |
| 1951 | 56 | Alfred McGuire | 6 | St. John's |
| 1951 | 66 | Sid Ryen | 7 | Denver |
| 1950 | 7 | Irwin Dambrot | 1 | City College of New York |
| 1950 | 19 | Herb Scherer | 2 | Long Island University |
| 1950 | 31 | Stan Weber | 3 | Bowling Green |
| 1950 | 43 | Joe Ossola | 4 | Saint Louis |
| 1950 | 55 | Dick Barnes | 5 | San Diego State |
| 1950 | 67 | Don Parsons | 6 | Rutgers University |
| 1950 | 79 | Dan Bagley | 7 | Notre Dame |
| 1950 | 91 | Charles Hope | 8 | Appalachian State University |
| 1950 | 103 | Don Heathington | 9 | Baylor |
| 1949 | 8 | Dick McGuire | 1T | St. John's |
| 1949 | 20 | Harry Gallatin | 2 | Truman State University |
| 1948 | 4 | Dolph Schayes | 1 | NYU |
| 1947 | 5 | Dick Holub | 1 | Long Island University |
