| 2025 | 37 | Chaz Lanier | 2 | Tennessee |
| 2024 | 5 | Ron Holland | 1 | |
| 2024 | 53 | Cam Spencer (↳MEM) | 2 | UConn |
| 2023 | 5 | Ausar Thompson | 1 | |
| 2023 | 31 | James Nnaji (↳BOS ↳CHO) | 2 | |
| 2022 | 5 | Jaden Ivey | 1 | Purdue |
| 2022 | 46 | Ismael Kamagate (↳POR ↳DEN) | 2 | |
| 2021 | 1 | Cade Cunningham | 1 | Oklahoma State |
| 2021 | 37 | JT Thor (↳CHO) | 2 | Auburn |
| 2021 | 42 | Isaiah Livers | 2 | Michigan |
| 2021 | 52 | Luka Garza | 2 | Iowa |
| 2020 | 7 | Killian Hayes | 1 | |
| 2019 | 15 | Sekou Doumbouya | 1 | |
| 2019 | 45 | Isaiah Roby (↳DAL) | 2 | Nebraska |
| 2018 | 42 | Bruce Brown | 2 | Miami (FL) |
| 2017 | 12 | Luke Kennard | 1 | Duke |
| 2016 | 18 | Henry Ellenson | 1 | Marquette |
| 2016 | 49 | Michael Gbinije | 2 | Syracuse |
| 2015 | 8 | Stanley Johnson | 1 | Arizona |
| 2015 | 38 | Darrun Hilliard | 2 | Villanova |
| 2014 | 38 | Spencer Dinwiddie | 2 | Colorado |
| 2013 | 8 | Kentavious Caldwell-Pope | 1 | Georgia |
| 2013 | 37 | Tony Mitchell | 2 | University of North Texas |
| 2013 | 56 | Peyton Siva | 2 | Louisville |
| 2012 | 9 | Andre Drummond | 1 | UConn |
| 2012 | 39 | Khris Middleton | 2 | Texas A&M |
| 2012 | 44 | Kim English | 2 | Missouri |
| 2011 | 8 | Brandon Knight | 1 | Kentucky |
| 2011 | 33 | Kyle Singler | 2 | Duke |
| 2011 | 52 | Vernon Macklin | 2 | Florida |
| 2010 | 7 | Greg Monroe | 1 | Georgetown |
| 2010 | 36 | Terrico White | 2 | Ole Miss |
| 2009 | 15 | Austin Daye | 1 | Gonzaga |
| 2009 | 35 | DaJuan Summers | 2 | Georgetown |
| 2009 | 39 | Jonas Jerebko | 2 | |
| 2009 | 44 | Chase Budinger (↳HOU) | 2 | Arizona |
| 2008 | 29 | D.J. White (↳SEA) | 1 | Indiana |
| 2008 | 59 | Deron Washington | 2 | Virginia Tech |
| 2007 | 15 | Rodney Stuckey | 1 | Eastern Washington |
| 2007 | 27 | Arron Afflalo | 1 | UCLA |
| 2007 | 57 | Sammy Mejia | 2 | DePaul |
| 2006 | 60 | Will Blalock | 2 | Iowa State |
| 2005 | 26 | Jason Maxiell | 1 | Cincinnati |
| 2005 | 56 | Amir Johnson | 2 | |
| 2005 | 60 | Alex Acker | 2 | Pepperdine |
| 2004 | 54 | Rickey Paulding | 2 | Missouri |
| 2003 | 2 | Darko Miličić | 1 | |
| 2003 | 25 | Carlos Delfino | 1 | |
| 2003 | 58 | Andreas Glyniadakis | 2 | |
| 2002 | 23 | Tayshaun Prince | 1 | Kentucky |
| 2001 | 9 | Rodney White | 1 | UNC Charlotte |
| 2001 | 38 | Mehmet Okur | 2 | |
| 2000 | 14 | Mateen Cleaves | 1 | Michigan State |
| 2000 | 44 | Brian Cardinal | 2 | Purdue |
| 1999 | 54 | Melvin Levett | 2 | Cincinnati |
| 1998 | 11 | Bonzi Wells | 1 | Ball State University |
| 1998 | 40 | Korleone Young | 2 | |
| 1997 | 19 | Scot Pollard | 1 | Kansas |
| 1997 | 32 | Charles O'Bannon | 2 | UCLA |
| 1996 | 26 | Jerome Williams | 1 | Georgetown |
| 1995 | 18 | Theo Ratliff | 1 | Wyoming |
| 1995 | 19 | Randolph Childress (↳POR) | 1 | Wake Forest |
| 1995 | 30 | Lou Roe | 2 | UMass |
| 1995 | 58 | Don Reid | 2 | Georgetown |
| 1994 | 3 | Grant Hill | 1 | Duke |
| 1994 | 48 | Jevon Crudup | 2 | Missouri |
| 1993 | 10 | Lindsey Hunter | 1 | Jackson State University |
| 1993 | 11 | Allan Houston | 1 | Tennessee |
| 1992 | 19 | Don MacLean (↳LAC ↳WSB) | 1 | UCLA |
| 1991 | 40 | Doug Overton | 2 | La Salle |
| 1990 | 26 | Lance Blanks | 1 | Texas |
| 1989 | 27 | Kenny Battle (↳PHO) | 1 | Illinois |
| 1988 | 30 | Fennis Dembo | 2 | Wyoming |
| 1988 | 48 | Micheal Williams | 2 | Baylor |
| 1988 | 72 | Lee Johnson | 3 | Norfolk State |
| 1987 | 24 | Freddie Banks | 2 | UNLV |
| 1987 | 65 | Eric White | 3 | Pepperdine |
| 1987 | 88 | Dave Popson | 4 | UNC |
| 1987 | 111 | Gerry Wright | 5 | Iowa |
| 1987 | 134 | Antoine Joubert | 6 | Michigan |
| 1987 | 157 | Mark Gottfried | 7 | Alabama |
| 1986 | 11 | John Salley | 1 | Georgia Tech |
| 1986 | 27 | Dennis Rodman | 2 | Southeastern Oklahoma State University |
| 1986 | 86 | Chauncey Robinson | 4 | Mississippi State |
| 1986 | 109 | Clarence Hanley | 5 | Old Dominion |
| 1986 | 132 | Greg Grant | 6 | Utah State University |
| 1986 | 155 | Larry Polec | 7 | Michigan State |
| 1985 | 18 | Joe Dumars | 1 | McNeese State University |
| 1985 | 60 | Andre Goode | 3 | Northwestern |
| 1985 | 64 | Richie Johnson | 3 | University of Evansville |
| 1985 | 87 | Spud Webb | 4 | NC State |
| 1985 | 110 | Mike Lahm | 5 | Murray State |
| 1985 | 133 | Vincent Giles | 6 | Eastern Michigan |
| 1985 | 156 | Frank James | 7 | UNLV |
| 1984 | 20 | Tony Campbell | 1 | Ohio State |
| 1984 | 32 | Eric Turner | 2 | Michigan |
| 1984 | 66 | Kevin Springman | 3 | Saint Joseph's |
| 1984 | 89 | Phillip Smith | 4 | New Mexico |
| 1984 | 112 | Rick Doyle | 5 | Texas-San Antonio |
| 1984 | 135 | Rennie Bailey | 6 | Louisiana Tech |
| 1984 | 158 | Barry Francisco | 7 | Bloomsburg University of Pennsylvania |
| 1984 | 181 | Dale Roberts | 8 | Appalachian State University |
| 1984 | 203 | Ben Tower | 9 | Michigan State |
| 1984 | 225 | Dan Pelekoudas | 10 | Michigan |
| 1983 | 8 | Antoine Carr | 1 | Wichita State |
| 1983 | 55 | Erich Santifer | 3 | Syracuse |
| 1983 | 78 | Steve Bouchie | 4 | Indiana |
| 1983 | 101 | Ken Austin | 5 | Rice University |
| 1983 | 124 | Derek Perry | 6 | Michigan State |
| 1983 | 147 | Rob Gonzalez | 7 | Colorado |
| 1983 | 170 | George Wenzel | 8 | Augustana College (IL) |
| 1983 | 192 | Marlow McLain | 9 | Eastern Michigan |
| 1983 | 213 | Ike Person | 10 | Michigan |
| 1982 | 9 | Cliff Levingston | 1 | Wichita State |
| 1982 | 18 | Ricky Pierce | 1 | Rice University |
| 1982 | 78 | Walker Russell | 4 | Western Michigan |
| 1982 | 101 | John Ebeling | 5 | Florida Southern College |
| 1982 | 124 | Gary Holmes | 6 | Minnesota |
| 1982 | 147 | Dean Marquardt | 7 | Marquette |
| 1982 | 170 | Brian Nyenhuis | 8 | Marquette |
| 1982 | 193 | Kevin Smith | 9 | Michigan State |
| 1982 | 214 | David Coulthard | 10 | |
| 1981 | 2 | Isiah Thomas | 1 | Indiana |
| 1981 | 12 | Kelly Tripucka | 1 | Notre Dame |
| 1981 | 71 | John May | 4 | University of South Alabama |
| 1981 | 89 | Don Koonce | 4 | UNC Charlotte |
| 1981 | 94 | George DeVone | 5 | UNC Charlotte |
| 1981 | 117 | Vince Brookins | 6 | Iowa |
| 1981 | 140 | Greg Nance | 7 | West Virginia |
| 1981 | 163 | Joe Schoen | 8 | Saint Francis University |
| 1981 | 185 | Eddie Baker | 9 | Alcorn State |
| 1981 | 205 | Melvin Maxwell | 10 | Western Michigan |
| 1980 | 17 | Larry Drew | 1 | Missouri |
| 1980 | 45 | Brad Branson | 2 | SMU |
| 1980 | 64 | Jonathan Moore | 3 | Furman University |
| 1980 | 70 | Darwin Cook | 4 | University of Portland |
| 1980 | 93 | Tony Fuller | 5 | Pepperdine |
| 1980 | 116 | Tony Turner | 6 | University of Alaska Anchorage |
| 1980 | 139 | Carl Pierce | 7 | Gonzaga |
| 1980 | 161 | Leroy Loggins | 8 | Fairmont State University |
| 1980 | 180 | Terry DuPris | 9 | Huron University |
| 1979 | 4 | Greg Kelser | 1 | Michigan State |
| 1979 | 10 | Roy Hamilton | 1 | UCLA |
| 1979 | 15 | Phil Hubbard | 1 | Michigan |
| 1979 | 29 | Tony Price | 2 | Penn |
| 1979 | 48 | Terry Duerod | 3 | Detroit Mercy |
| 1979 | 92 | Flintie Ray Williams | 5 | UNLV |
| 1979 | 111 | Truman Claytor | 6 | Kentucky |
| 1979 | 132 | Ken Jones | 7 | Saint Mary's |
| 1979 | 150 | Rodney Lee | 8 | Memphis |
| 1979 | 170 | Val Bracey | 9 | Central Michigan University |
| 1979 | 187 | Willie Polk | 10 | Grand Canyon University |
| 1978 | 23 | Terry Tyler | 2 | Detroit Mercy |
| 1978 | 29 | John Long | 2 | Detroit Mercy |
| 1978 | 95 | Dave Caligaris | 5 | Northeastern University |
| 1978 | 117 | Audie Matthews | 6 | Illinois |
| 1978 | 138 | Herb Entzminger | 7 | Johnson C. Smith University |
| 1978 | 157 | Earl Evans | 8 | UNLV |
| 1978 | 174 | Ulice Payne | 9 | Marquette |
| 1978 | 189 | Dave Grauzer | 10 | Central Michigan University |
| 1977 | 36 | Ben Poquette | 2 | Central Michigan University |
| 1977 | 58 | John Irving | 3 | Hofstra |
| 1977 | 80 | Bruce King | 4 | Iowa |
| 1977 | 102 | Jim Kennedy | 5 | Missouri |
| 1977 | 124 | Herb Nobles | 6 | Kansas |
| 1977 | 144 | Robert Lewis | 7 | Johnson C. Smith University |
| 1977 | 163 | Tim Appleton | 8 | Kenyon College |
| 1976 | 4 | Leon Douglas | 1 | Alabama |
| 1976 | 38 | Phil Sellers | 3 | Rutgers University |
| 1976 | 55 | Scott Thompson | 4 | Iowa |
| 1976 | 72 | Jim Hearns | 5 | Marymount College |
| 1976 | 90 | Russell Davis | 6 | Virginia Tech |
| 1976 | 108 | Curt Peterson | 7 | University of Puget Sound |
| 1976 | 126 | Randy Henry | 8 | Illinois State |
| 1976 | 144 | Bill Martin | 9 | Hartwick College |
| 1976 | 161 | Bob Johnson | 10 | Wisconsin |
| 1975 | 27 | Walter Luckett | 2 | Ohio University |
| 1975 | 44 | Pete Trgovich | 3 | UCLA |
| 1975 | 64 | Lindsay Hairston | 4 | Michigan State |
| 1975 | 81 | Cliff Pratt | 5 | Shaw |
| 1975 | 98 | Allen Spruill | 6 | North Carolina A&T |
| 1975 | 118 | Ike Williams | 7 | Armstrong Atlantic State University |
| 1975 | 135 | John Kelley | 8 | Dillard University |
| 1975 | 151 | Terry Thomas | 9 | Detroit Mercy |
| 1975 | 169 | Mickey Fox | 10 | Saint Mary's University |
| 1974 | 15 | Al Eberhard (↳SSL) | 1 | Missouri |
| 1974 | 33 | Eric Money | 2 | Arizona |
| 1974 | 51 | Roland Grant | 3 | New Mexico State |
| 1974 | 69 | Mickey Martin | 4 | Pitt |
| 1974 | 87 | Joe Newman | 5 | Temple |
| 1974 | 105 | Mike Sylvester | 6 | Dayton |
| 1974 | 123 | Sammy High | 7 | Tulsa |
| 1974 | 141 | Greg Newman | 8 | Drexel |
| 1974 | 158 | Gary Deitelhoff | 9 | Millikin University |
| 1974 | 175 | Bill Ligon | 10 | Vanderbilt |
| 1973 | 44 | Bo Lamar | 3 | Louisiana |
| 1973 | 50 | Larry Kenon (↳NYA) | 3 | Memphis |
| 1973 | 61 | Ken Brady | 4 | Michigan |
| 1973 | 78 | Henry Wilmore | 5 | Michigan |
| 1973 | 95 | Dennis Johnson | 6 | Ferris State University |
| 1973 | 112 | Fred Smiley | 7 | Northwood University |
| 1973 | 129 | Ben Kelso | 8 | Central Michigan University |
| 1973 | 145 | Bill Kilgore | 9 | Michigan State |
| 1973 | 159 | Bob Solomon | 10 | Wayne State University |
| 1973 | 171 | Len Paul | 11 | University of Akron |
| 1973 | 180 | Clarence Carlisle | 12 | Ferris State University |
| 1972 | 9 | Bob Nash | 1 | Hawaii |
| 1972 | 17 | Chris Ford | 2 | Villanova |
| 1972 | 51 | Ernie Fleming | 4 | Jacksonville University |
| 1972 | 67 | Ernest Pettis | 5 | Western Michigan |
| 1972 | 84 | Terry Benton | 6 | Wichita State |
| 1972 | 101 | Bruce Anderson | 7 | Arizona |
| 1972 | 117 | Ben Kelso | 8 | Central Michigan University |
| 1972 | 133 | Jesse Mangham | 9 | Ferris State University |
| 1972 | 146 | Kent Hollenbeck | 10 | Kentucky |
| 1971 | 11 | Curtis Rowe | 1 | UCLA |
| 1971 | 29 | Isaiah Wilson | 2 | University of Baltimore |
| 1971 | 45 | Marv Roberts | 3 | Utah State University |
| 1971 | 62 | Jarrett Durham | 4 | Duquesne |
| 1971 | 79 | Vincent White | 5 | Savannah State University |
| 1971 | 96 | Jim Larranaga | 6 | Providence |
| 1971 | 113 | Steve Kelly | 7 | BYU |
| 1971 | 130 | Wayne Jones | 8 | Niagara University |
| 1971 | 146 | Paul Botts | 9 | Central Michigan University |
| 1971 | 162 | Steve Butcher | 10 | Pikeville College |
| 1971 | 177 | Larry Saunders | 11 | Duke |
| 1971 | 190 | Bob Horn | 12 | Drake University |
| 1971 | 202 | Willie Roberson | 13 | Wyoming |
| 1971 | 212 | Art Davis | 14 | Johnson C. Smith University |
| 1971 | 221 | James Fleming | 15 | Alcorn State |
| 1971 | 228 | Fred Smiley | 16 | Davenport University |
| 1971 | 232 | Leroy Jenkins | 17 | Davenport University |
| 1971 | 235 | Ike Bundy | 18 | Detroit Institute of Technology |
| 1971 | 237 | Greg Jenkins | 19 | Shaw |
| 1970 | 1 | Bob Lanier | 1 | St. Bonaventure |
| 1970 | 32 | Ken Warzynski | 2 | DePaul |
| 1970 | 37 | Bob St. Pierre | 3 | Hanover College |
| 1970 | 47 | Jim Hayes | 3 | Boston University |
| 1970 | 71 | Bill Jankans | 5 | Cal State Long Beach |
| 1970 | 88 | Sevira Brown | 6 | DePaul |
| 1970 | 105 | Marv Copeland | 7 | Shaw College (MI) |
| 1970 | 122 | Dan Issel | 8 | Kentucky |
| 1970 | 139 | Alex Winn | 9 | Dartmouth College |
| 1970 | 156 | Bruce Chapman | 10 | UNLV |
| 1970 | 172 | Rick Anheuser | 11 | NC State |
| 1970 | 185 | Don Ogletree | 12 | Cincinnati |
| 1970 | 195 | Ernest Hardy | 13 | Harvard University |
| 1970 | 205 | Randy Smith | 14 | Buffalo State |
| 1970 | 215 | Denis Clark | 15 | Springfield College |
| 1970 | 224 | Harvey Mariatt | 16 | Eastern Michigan |
| 1969 | 4 | Terry Driscoll | 1 | Boston College |
| 1969 | 19 | Willie Norwood | 2 | Alcorn State |
| 1969 | 47 | Ted Wierman | 4 | Washington State |
| 1969 | 61 | Steve Mix | 5 | Toledo |
| 1969 | 75 | Larry Jeffries | 6 | Trinity University |
| 1969 | 89 | Steve Vandenberg | 7 | Duke |
| 1969 | 103 | Bob Arnzen | 8 | Notre Dame |
| 1969 | 117 | George Reynolds | 9 | Houston |
| 1969 | 131 | Bill English | 10 | Winston-Salem State |
| 1969 | 145 | Rusty Clark | 11 | UNC |
| 1968 | 6 | Otto Moore | 1 | University of Texas Rio Grande Valley |
| 1968 | 20 | Manny Leaks | 2 | Niagara University |
| 1968 | 25 | Don Dee | 3 | Saint Mary of the Plains College |
| 1968 | 42 | Rich Niemann | 4 | Saint Louis |
| 1968 | 56 | Carl Fuller | 5 | Bethune-Cookman College |
| 1968 | 70 | Wally Anderzunas | 6 | Creighton |
| 1968 | 84 | Larry Newbold | 7 | Long Island University |
| 1968 | 98 | Harry Laurie | 8 | Saint Peter's College |
| 1968 | 112 | Vaughn Harper | 9 | Syracuse |
| 1968 | 126 | Tom Baack | 10 | Nebraska |
| 1967 | 1 | Jimmy Walker | 1 | Providence |
| 1967 | 4 | Sonny Dove | 1 | St. John's |
| 1967 | 14 | Steve Sullivan | 2 | Georgetown |
| 1967 | 21 | Darrell Hardy | 3 | Baylor |
| 1967 | 33 | Ronald Franz | 4 | Kansas |
| 1967 | 45 | Paul Long | 5 | Wake Forest |
| 1967 | 57 | Vaughn Harper | 6 | Syracuse |
| 1967 | 69 | Bobby Lloyd | 7 | Rutgers University |
| 1967 | 81 | George Carter | 8 | St. Bonaventure |
| 1967 | 125 | George Dalzell | 12 | Colgate |
| 1967 | 135 | Matthew Aitch | 13 | Michigan State |
| 1966 | 2 | Dave Bing | 1 | Syracuse |
| 1966 | 12 | Dorie Murrey | 2 | Detroit Mercy |
| 1966 | 22 | Ollie Darden | 3 | Michigan |
| 1966 | 32 | Jeffrey Congdon | 4 | BYU |
| 1966 | 42 | William Pickens | 5 | Georgia Southern University |
| 1966 | 52 | Carroll Hooser | 6 | SMU |
| 1966 | 61 | Ted Manning | 7 | NC Central |
| 1966 | 70 | George McNeil | 8 | Southern Illinois |
| 1965 | 3 | Bill Buntin | 1T | Michigan |
| 1965 | 14 | Tom Van Arsdale | 2 | Indiana |
| 1965 | 23 | Ron Reed | 3 | Notre Dame |
| 1965 | 32 | Jim King | 4 | Oklahoma State |
| 1965 | 41 | Ted Manning | 5 | NC Central |
| 1965 | 50 | Barry Smith | 6 | High Point University |
| 1964 | 2 | Joe Caldwell | 1 | Arizona State |
| 1964 | 11 | Les Hunter (↳BAL) | 2 | Loyola Chicago |
| 1964 | 20 | Wali Jones (↳BAL) | 3 | Villanova |
| 1964 | 29 | Jim Davis | 4 | Colorado |
| 1964 | 38 | Ray Wolford | 5 | Toledo |
| 1964 | 47 | Larry Phillips | 6 | Rice University |
| 1964 | 56 | Jerry Jackson | 7 | Ohio University |
| 1964 | 65 | Ralph Telken | 8 | Rockhurst University |
| 1963 | 4 | Eddie Miles | 1 | Seattle University |
| 1963 | 13 | Jerry Smith | 2 | Furman University |
| 1963 | 22 | Mike McCoy | 3 | Miami (FL) |
| 1963 | 31 | Dave Erickson | 4 | Marquette |
| 1963 | 40 | Bill Small | 5 | Illinois |
| 1963 | 49 | Reggie Harding | 6 | |
| 1963 | 58 | Ira Harge | 7 | New Mexico |
| 1963 | 67 | Gary Silc | 8 | Northern Michigan University |
| 1963 | 72 | Ernie Dunston | 9 | Seattle University |
| 1962 | 4 | Dave DeBusschere | 1T | Detroit Mercy |
| 1962 | 13 | Kevin Loughery | 2 | St. John's |
| 1962 | 22 | Harold Hudgens | 3 | Texas Tech |
| 1962 | 31 | Reggie Harding | 4 | |
| 1962 | 40 | Lindberg Moody | 5 | South Carolina |
| 1962 | 49 | Ed Noe | 6 | Morehead State University |
| 1962 | 58 | John Bradley | 7 | Lawrence University |
| 1962 | 66 | Mike Rice | 8 | Duquesne |
| 1962 | 75 | Bill Nelson | 9 | Hamline University |
| 1962 | 84 | Glenn Moore | 10 | Oregon |
| 1961 | 4 | Ray Scott | 1 | University of Portland |
| 1961 | 17 | Johnny Egan | 2 | Providence |
| 1961 | 26 | Doug Kistler | 3 | Duke |
| 1961 | 35 | George Finley | 4 | Tennessee State |
| 1961 | 44 | Danny Doyle | 5 | Belmont Abbey College |
| 1961 | 53 | Lee Patrone | 6 | West Virginia |
| 1961 | 62 | Bert Price | 7 | Wittenberg University |
| 1961 | 71 | Walter Ward | 8 | Hampton |
| 1961 | 79 | Peter Baltic | 9 | Penn State |
| 1961 | 86 | Wayne Monson | 10 | Northern Michigan University |
| 1961 | 94 | Richard Kraft | 11 | State University of New York at Brockport |
| 1960 | 4 | Jackie Moreland | 1 | Louisiana Tech |
| 1960 | 12 | Ron Johnson | 2 | Minnesota |
| 1960 | 20 | Frank Case | 3 | Dayton |
| 1960 | 28 | Ken Remley | 4 | West Virginia Wesleyan College |
| 1960 | 36 | Willie Jones | 5 | Northwestern |
| 1960 | 44 | Bill Lowry | 6 | Christian Brothers University |
| 1960 | 52 | Doug Moe | 7 | UNC |
| 1960 | 59 | Mike Yugovich | 8 | Youngstown State University |
| 1960 | 66 | Martin Holland | 9 | Kentucky Wesleyan College |
| 1960 | 73 | Joe Kennelly | 10 | Dayton |
| 1960 | 78 | Mel Peterson | 11 | Wheaton College |
| 1960 | 83 | John Dobbert | 12 | Wheaton College |
| 1960 | 88 | Lee Hopfenspirger | 13 | Hamline University |
| 1959 | 2 | Bailey Howell | 1 | Mississippi State |
| 1959 | 9 | Tom Robitaille | 2 | Rice University |
| 1959 | 10 | Don Goldstein | 2 | Louisville |
| 1959 | 18 | Gary Alcorn | 3 | Fresno State |
| 1959 | 26 | George Lee | 4 | Michigan |
| 1959 | 34 | Tony Windis | 5 | Wyoming |
| 1959 | 42 | Lou Jordan | 6 | Cornell |
| 1959 | 50 | Doug Smart | 7 | Washington |
| 1959 | 57 | Chuck Curtis | 8 | Pacific Lutheran University |
| 1959 | 63 | Doyle Edmiston | 9 | Hardin-Simmons University |
| 1959 | 69 | Bruno Boin | 10 | Washington |
| 1959 | 75 | M.C. Burton | 11 | Michigan |
| 1958 | 11 | Barney Cable | 2 | Bradley |
| 1958 | 19 | Roy DeWitz | 3 | Kansas State |
| 1958 | 27 | Ralph Crosthwaite | 4 | Western Kentucky |
| 1958 | 35 | Hank Morano | 5 | Saint Peter's College |
| 1958 | 43 | Shellie McMillon | 6 | Bradley |
| 1958 | 51 | Ed Blair | 7 | Western Michigan |
| 1958 | 59 | Jack Quiggle | 8 | Michigan State |
| 1958 | 66 | Harry Marske | 9 | North Dakota State University |
| 1958 | 72 | Pete Gaudin | 10 | Loyola New Orleans |
| 1958 | 77 | Herb Merritt | 11 | Tennessee Technological University |
| 1958 | 81 | Jim Dew | 12 | Alabama State University |
| 1957 | 2 | Charlie Tyra | 1 | Louisville |
| 1957 | 10 | Bob McCoy | 2 | Grambling State University |
| 1957 | 18 | Bill Ebben | 3 | Detroit Mercy |
| 1957 | 26 | Kurt Engelbert | 4 | Saint Joseph's |
| 1957 | 34 | Ron Kramer | 5 | Michigan |
| 1957 | 42 | Walt Adamushko | 6 | St. Francis College |
| 1957 | 50 | Carl Boldt | 7 | San Francisco |
| 1957 | 57 | Doug Bolstorff | 8 | Minnesota |
| 1957 | 64 | Bob Lazor | 9 | Pitt |
| 1956 | 7 | Ron Sobie (↳NYK) | 1 | DePaul |
| 1956 | 15 | Bob Kessler | 2 | Maryland |
| 1956 | 23 | Bill Thieben | 3 | Hofstra |
| 1956 | 31 | Charles Slack | 4 | Marshall |
| 1956 | 39 | Joe Liebler | 5 | Holy Cross |
| 1956 | 47 | Paul Schlimm | 6 | John Carroll University |
| 1956 | 55 | Bruce Harris | 7 | Tennessee Technological University |
| 1955 | 8 | Johnny Horan | 1 | Dayton |
| 1955 | 15 | Jesse Arnelle | 2 | Penn State |
| 1955 | 24 | Ron Bennink | 3 | Washington State |
| 1955 | 31 | Dick Howard | 4 | Case Western Reserve University |
| 1955 | 40 | Cleo Littleton | 5 | Wichita State |
| 1955 | 47 | Bob Reiter | 6 | Missouri |
| 1955 | 56 | Tom Harrold | 7 | Colorado |
| 1955 | 63 | Don Belcher | 8 | LSU |
| 1955 | 72 | Tom Mixon | 9 | Mercer University |
| 1955 | 79 | Charlie Mock | 10 | Colorado |
| 1955 | 87 | Happy Mahfouz | 11 | Spring Hill College |
| 1955 | 92 | Ray Warren | 12 | TCU |
| 1954 | 4 | Dick Rosenthal | 1T | Notre Dame |
| 1954 | 13 | Arnold Short | 2 | Oklahoma City University |
| 1954 | 22 | B.H. Born | 3 | Kansas |
| 1954 | 31 | Mel Thompson | 4 | NC State |
| 1954 | 40 | Dutch Burch | 5 | Pitt |
| 1954 | 49 | Charles Kraak | 6 | Indiana |
| 1954 | 58 | Bernie Janicki | 7 | Duke |
| 1954 | 67 | Don Bielke | 8 | Valparaiso |
| 1954 | 76 | Joel Hittleman | 9 | Loyola (MD) |
| 1954 | 84 | Dean Larsen | 10 | BYU |
| 1954 | 93 | Forrest Jackson | 11 | Taylor University |
| 1953 | 4 | Jack Molinas | 1 | Columbia University |
| 1953 | 13 | George Glasgow | 2 | Fairleigh Dickinson University |
| 1952 | 3 | Dick Groat | 1 | Duke |
| 1951 | 4 | Zeke Sinicola | 1 | Niagara University |
| 1951 | 14 | Jack Kiley | 2 | Syracuse |
| 1951 | 24 | Jake Fendley | 3 | Northwestern |
| 1951 | 34 | Herb Hargett | 4 | Mississippi State |
| 1951 | 44 | Leo Johnson | 5 | Arizona |
| 1951 | 54 | Frank Calsbeek | 6 | Iowa |
| 1951 | 64 | Jim Ramstead | 7 | Stanford |
| 1951 | 74 | John Manning | 8 | Duquesne |
| 1950 | 8 | George Yardley | 1 | Stanford |
| 1950 | 20 | Jim Riffey | 2 | Tulane |
| 1950 | 32 | Art Burris | 3 | Tennessee |
| 1950 | 44 | Len Rzeszewski | 4 | Indiana State University |
| 1950 | 56 | Leroy Thompson | 5 | Kent State University |
| 1950 | 68 | Bob Metcalf | 6 | Valparaiso |
| 1950 | 80 | Hugh Jones | 7 | Tennessee |
| 1950 | 92 | Billy Adcock | 8 | Vanderbilt |
| 1950 | 104 | Al Henningsen | 9 | Northwest Missouri State University |
| 1949 | 3 | Bob Harris | 1 | Oklahoma State |
| 1949 | 15 | John Oldham | 2 | Western Kentucky |
| 1948 | 8 | Ward Williams | 1 | Indiana |
